The Success of Canada Goose and the Challenges of Shinola
Canada Goose, a winter-wear producer, has managed to transform itself into the fastest-growing luxury company in the world by leveraging its authentic foundation and functional benefits. The brand, which started in a garage in Toronto, gained luxury associations through endorsements from high-status individuals and an emphasis on craftsmanship. On the other hand, Shinola, a brand that attempted to reposition itself as a luxury wristwatch brand, faced difficulties in aligning its brand associations with its aspirations. Despite its initial success, Shinola struggled with a lack of coherent messaging and faced challenges with its product authenticity. Recognizing the need to regroup, Shinola shifted its focus to a mass-market clientele. These examples highlight the challenges of recasting a heritage brand and the importance of crafting a compelling story to communicate authenticity in the luxury market. Additionally, established brands must be cautious when attempting to elevate a mass-market brand to luxury status, as it can be challenging to change consumer perceptions.
Implications for the US Business Market and New Companies
The contrasting tales of Canada Goose and Shinola offer valuable insights for the US business market and emerging companies. The success of Canada Goose underscores the power of authenticity and the strategic use of endorsements in carving a niche in the luxury market. This indicates that even businesses starting from humble beginnings can ascend to luxury status, provided they leverage their unique strengths and build strong brand associations.
Challenges in Recasting Brands
Shinola's struggle, on the other hand, highlights the difficulties in repositioning a brand, especially when its heritage and current aspirations are misaligned. This serves as a cautionary tale for businesses attempting to elevate their status without a coherent strategy or authentic product narrative.
Lessons for New Companies
For new companies, these examples underscore the importance of clear and consistent messaging, as well as the need for authenticity in product offerings. They also highlight the potential pitfalls of trying to elevate a mass-market brand to luxury status without careful planning and strategic execution. Ultimately, these cases emphasize the importance of understanding consumer perceptions and crafting compelling brand stories in the pursuit of luxury status.
Original Story By: Kellogg School of Management at Northwestern University
.svg)
